Keresés RSS

The eternal dilemma No2.: Alfa or BMW?

Alfa 159 Vs. BMW E46 320D

14/03/2014 06:45 |  Comments: 
I do 30 thousand km a year, I have a sporty driving style. Which one should I go for, the Alfa 159 1.9, 2.0 JTD (made after 2008), or the BMW E46 320d with 150 PS (made after 2004)?

Totalcarmagazine's own Buyer's guide

Dear Friendly Car Dealer,

I’ve never thought I would ask for help buying a car one day as I’m the kind browsing used car ads all day long. At times anything from the Uno Turbo to the Mercedes G looks interesting to me.

My 2007 BMW E92 is a fussy car. It’s been serving me from 3 years, but not nearly as reliably as the E46 I had before. It must go.

My question: I do about 30 thousand km a year, I have a sporty driving style (I have sent you a picture taken at this year’s trackday showing us chasing each other). Which one should I go for, the Alfa 159 1.9, 2.0 JTD (made after 2008), or the BMW E46 320d with 150 PS (made after 2004)? These are the two I like most. I don’t care about the body, even a convertible could cut it, but I definitely need a car with a manual gearbox. I don’t care much about the price, either, as we’re talking cheaper cars here than what I currently own (let’s say the upper limit is at 9,600 €).

Am I right in being scared of the „unreliability” of Italian cars? Is my mind playing a trick on me glorifying the time spent with my E46? What do you reckon?



Dear Áron,

for this money you can get the most beautiful BMWs with M-package. I think the E46 is a very good car, but you should keep an eye on these things. If you don’t insist on the M-package, for about 6,500 € or a bit over you can easily buy a car abroad that hasn’t done more than 150-160 thousand km. The Alfa 159 is a personal favourite of mine, with one of the most beautifully designed shapes of the past 10 years. In the right colour it’s striking. I particularly like the estate. Its multijet engine is great and totally reliable. I recommend you go and have a look at as many as you can of both models and simply go for the one that makes your heart skip a beat.


Friendly Car Dealer

"Dear Friendly Car Dealer" is a regular column in the Hungarian edition of Totalcar Magazine. Our Agony Aunt has been trading cars for over 20 years and knows just about everything there is to know about used cars. Should you have any questions for our expert, please send your email to 

Dear reader, please like us whether you came here intentionally or not. We'll like you too!

Follow Us On Facebook!
pick of the litterUsed Cars

Alex warned me

It was ready to be retired at the rental agency, only returned to service at our specific request. I was expecting a tiger; it turned out to be a mule.